UAE AI Liability Falls on Companies, Says Ashish Mehta

UAE AI Liability Falls on Companies, Says Ashish Mehta

Estimated reading time: 8 minutes · Last updated:

When a business acts on AI-generated advice and someone suffers financial loss or harm, the injured party's claim under UAE law normally runs against the business. That is the reading of Ashish Mehta, founder and managing partner of Ashish Mehta & Associates. The Civil Transactions Law contains no dedicated regime for AI output, so UAE AI liability is settled through its ordinary rules on harmful acts, alongside contracts and any sector rules. Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025 promulgated that law. Once the company has paid, it can turn on a negligent partner, a manager who exceeded his powers or a bad-faith employee. It can pursue the AI developer only through their contract, because the December 2022 ethics guidance for developers is not binding.

Key takeaways

  • No AI-specific regime: Ashish Mehta says the Civil Transactions Law, promulgated by Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025, has no separate liability rules for AI. Its general harmful-act provisions in Articles 245 to 247 may apply instead.
  • Company answers first: In Mehta's analysis, a person harmed by a company's AI-driven decision has recourse against the company itself. The company's liability can rest on weak vetting, thin safeguards or poor monitoring of the system.
  • Professional firms bound: Article 651 makes a professional company liable to third parties for its partners' faults. It also voids any articles-of-association clause that exempts a manager from personal liability.
  • Developer guidance is soft law: The UAE's AI Ethics: Principles and Guidelines of December 2022 split accountability among those who design, develop and deploy AI. The guidelines describe themselves as non-binding.
  • Staff can face dismissal: Article 44 of Decree Law No (33) of 2021 allows dismissal without notice for an admitted error causing gross material losses. The employer must notify the Ministry of Human Resources and Emiratisation within 7 working days.

How a 2025 Civil Code Reaches Harm Caused by AI

The UAE's Civil Transactions Law, promulgated by Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025, never mentions artificial intelligence. Mehta is qualified to practise in Dubai, the United Kingdom and India. He argues its rules on harmful acts may still govern AI cases. Article 245(1) applies those rules to harmful acts by any natural or legal person, unless special legislation provides otherwise.

Article 246 sets the baseline duty. It reads: "Every act causing harm to another shall obligate its perpetrator to compensate for the damage, even if the perpetrator lacks discernment." Article 245(1) addresses natural and legal persons, so the practical question in an AI dispute is which person's act produced the loss. The software itself is not that person.

Article 247 separates two routes to liability. Harm done directly creates a guarantee, which here means an obligation to compensate, with no further condition attached. Harm by causation is harm that follows indirectly from an act. It creates that obligation only if the perpetrator was a transgressor, acted intentionally, or the act led to the harm. Mehta says AI cases will therefore turn on three things. The first is each party's part in building, deploying or using the system. The second is what was done or omitted. The third is whether that conduct links closely enough to the damage.

Why the Company Using the Tool Usually Carries the Loss

Mehta's central point is that treating AI as a tool does not shield whoever chose to use it. In his reading, the deploying person or entity may still be liable.

A company is exposed when harm from an AI system used in its operations can be pinned on something it did or failed to do. He gives three examples of conduct that could found a claim. The first is assessing the system too lightly before relying on it. The second is surrounding it with too few safeguards. The third is failing to supervise how it is used once it is running.

Other factors can shift the outcome. These include the company's contracts with the affected party, any regulatory requirements in its sector, and how closely it was involved in the particular decision. For a compliance team, the practical consequence follows directly. Records showing how an AI system was evaluated and overseen are likely to weigh as heavily in a dispute as the faulty output itself.

Professional Firms Cannot Contract Out of AI-Assisted Errors

Mehta says the position is clearer for professional companies. Article 645 defines one as a company formed by one or more people licensed in a liberal profession, alone or with others. Its purpose is to practise that profession, unless the law or the agreement says otherwise. Law and accounting firms are the obvious examples.

Article 651 sets the chain of responsibility. Each partner is personally liable to the firm and to fellow partners for professional faults, while the firm answers to third parties for those faults. The firm is also bound by its managers' conduct in the ordinary course of management. It is further bound by an employee or agent with authority to act for it, where a third party relied on that authority.

Clause 3 of the same article voids any provision in a firm's articles of association that lets a current or former manager be released from personal liability. Mehta concludes that a professional company stays liable for its services whether or not the work leaned on AI-generated advice. In his view, neither its founding documents nor side agreements can remove that liability.

What the 2022 AI Ethics Guidelines Ask of Developers

For developers, Mehta points to AI Ethics: Principles and Guidelines, issued in December 2022 by the UAE Ministry of State for Artificial Intelligence, Digital Economy and Remote Work Applications. Article 3.2.1 states: "Accountability for the outcomes of an AI system lies not with the system itself but is apportioned between those who design, develop and deploy it."

Article 3.2.2.1 suggests that operators and developers consider naming individuals to investigate and correct the causes of loss or damage from deployed systems. Article 3.5.1 sets a principle that developers should ensure their systems do not cause unintentional harm or adverse impacts. The guidelines also describe ways for people affected by significant AI-assisted decisions to contest them and ask for human review.

The limit is stated in the guidelines themselves, which declare that they are non-binding. Mehta therefore treats them as policy guidance and not as a freestanding basis for liability. A company that wants to recover from the vendor of a flawed model must rely on the contract between them. That puts the drafting of indemnities and warranties at the centre of any AI procurement.

How Employers Can Pursue Partners, Managers and Staff

After answering the injured party, the company can look inward. Where a partner delivered the service, Mehta says that partner remains personally liable to the firm for losses flowing from the third-party claim. Under clause 3 of Article 614 of the Civil Transactions Law, a manager who goes beyond the powers set in the contract is liable for resulting damage to the company.

Employees fall under Article 44 of Decree Law No (33) of 2021 on the Regulations of Employment Relations. That article permits dismissal without notice, but only after a written investigation and through a written, reasoned decision. Mehta highlights four grounds. Clause 2 covers an admitted error causing gross material losses, or deliberate damage to company property. In those cases the employer must report the incident to the Ministry of Human Resources and Emiratisation within 7 working days of learning of it.

Clause 3 covers breaches of written, visibly posted safety bylaws that the employee was told about. Clause 4 covers failing to perform core contractual duties despite a written investigation and two warnings. Clause 9 covers abusing a position for personal gain. Mehta applies these routes to managers acting outside the ordinary course of business and to unauthorised employees acting in bad faith.

Who answers for AI-driven harm under UAE law, in Ashish Mehta's analysis
Party Legal basis Exposure
Company using AI Civil Transactions Law Arts 245-247 Direct recourse for the injured party
Professional firm Art 651 Liable to third parties; exemption clauses void
Partner Art 651(1) Personally liable to firm and partners
Manager Art 614(3) Liable if contract powers exceeded
Employee Art 44, Decree Law No (33) of 2021 Dismissal without notice on listed grounds
AI developer Contract; 2022 AI Ethics Guidelines Contract terms only; guidelines non-binding

Where UAE AI liability is clear and where it is not

The case for

  • Article 246 imposes a broad duty to compensate for harm, so injured parties are not left without a remedy just because AI was involved.
  • Article 651 gives clients of professional firms a defendant that cannot hide behind exemption clauses in its articles of association.
  • The 2022 guidelines already set out how affected people can challenge significant AI-assisted decisions and seek human review.

The case against

  • The Civil Transactions Law has no AI-specific provisions, so causation under Article 247 must be argued case by case.
  • The developer-facing guidelines are expressly non-binding, leaving companies dependent on contract terms to recover from vendors.
  • Mehta's analysis is one practitioner's reading; no court ruling applying these articles to AI is cited.

What to be careful about

  • A company that cannot show how it vetted and monitored an AI system may struggle to defend a harmful-act claim under Articles 246 and 247.
  • Firms that bought AI tools without strong indemnities may absorb losses they cannot pass back to the developer.
  • Professional firms relying on articles-of-association exemptions for managers face Article 651(3), which voids them.
  • Employers that skip the written investigation or the 7-working-day ministry notice may weaken a dismissal under Article 44.

The bottom line

Mehta's reading leaves little room for a company to blame the algorithm. Liability under the Civil Transactions Law attaches to persons, so the business that deployed the system is the injured party's natural target. Article 651 tightens that position for professional firms. Recovery then moves along the chain: from partners under Article 651, managers under Article 614 and employees under Article 44, and from developers only through contract. The weakest link for companies is the developer, because the December 2022 guidelines carry no binding force. Until legislators or courts say more, the practical defences are documented vetting, active monitoring and AI vendor contracts that allocate risk explicitly. The open question is how judges will apply Article 247's causation test to a model's error.

What to watch

  • Watch for any UAE sector-specific legislation that sets its own AI liability rules, which Article 245(1) of the Civil Transactions Law would allow to take precedence; no date has been set.
  • Watch for the first UAE court decision applying the direct-versus-causation test in Article 247 to an AI-driven loss; no date has been set.
  • Watch whether the December 2022 AI Ethics Guidelines are revised or given binding force; no date has been set.

Frequently asked questions

Does the UAE have a specific law on AI liability?

Ashish Mehta says the Civil Transactions Law, promulgated by Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025, creates no separate regime for AI output. Its general harmful-act rules, contracts and any sector legislation fill the gap. The December 2022 AI Ethics Guidelines describe themselves as non-binding.

Can a UAE company sue the developer of a faulty AI tool?

In Mehta's view, a company's claim against an AI developer depends on the contract between them. The 2022 guidelines say developers should ensure their systems cause no unintentional harm. Because the guidelines are not binding, they do not create liability on their own.

Can an employee in the UAE be fired for a costly AI mistake?

Article 44 of Decree Law No (33) of 2021 allows dismissal without notice for an admitted error causing gross material losses. The dismissal must follow a written investigation, and the employer must notify the Ministry of Human Resources and Emiratisation within 7 working days.

Can a professional firm exempt its managers from liability in its articles?

No. Clause 3 of Article 651 voids any provision in a professional company's articles of association that frees a current or former manager from personal liability.



Share:

Categories

Newest course every month

Advertise your offline course to a wider audience with our landing page.

You May Also Like

UAE AI liability for harmful AI advice falls mainly on the company using it, lawyer Ashish Mehta argues, citing the...
  • November 15, 2026
AI privilege waiver is not automatic after Heppner, Norton Rose Fulbright lawyers argue, citing Morgan, Assini and a Texas Business...
  • November 13, 2026
California SB 574 bars lawyers and arbitrators from handing judgment to generative AI, requires citation checks and disclosure, and starts...
  • November 13, 2026